Click here to download a printable pdf version of the menu



The Local
American cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, LOCAL sauce. $5.95

PB & B
Peanut butter, bacon, us on this one. $6.99

Cheddar, bacon, jalapeños, onions, horseradish pickle chips, sriracha mayo. $6.89

Bacon, American cheese, fried egg, organic ketchup. $7.99

Pulled pork, slaw, pickles, house BBQ sauce. $6.99

Bleu Ribbon Burger
Bleu cheese, bacon, sautéed onions. $6.99

Return of the Mac
Bacon, cheddar, homemade mac-n-cheese. $6.99

Quinoa Burger
House-made quinoa and black bean patty, Swiss, lettuce, tomatoes, onions, pickles, sriracha mayo. $6.99

The Captain
Hand-breaded fried chicken sandwich. Chipotle ranch, slaw, pickles. $7.99

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Sweet-tea-brined grilled chicken breast, cheddar cheese, fried onion strings, lettuce, tomato, pickles, house BBQ. $7.99

*Substitute quinoa patty for any burger for $1

*Substitute a Gluten Free bun for $1.50

*Substitute grilled or fried chicken for $1


Choose Your Patty: Single $4.99, Double $7.49

Cheese: American, Cheddar, Swiss $0.99 each Bleu $1.25

Sauces: Organic ketchup, LOCAL sauce, BBQ sauce, honey mustard, horseradish mayo, garlic aioli, relish, sriracha aioli, maple mayo, mustard, mayo, ranch

Fixings: green leaf lettuce, tomato, onion, sautéed onion, jalapeños, horseradish pickle chips, dill pickle chips, slaw, sautéed mushrooms (.25)

Add-Ons: Bacon, chili, baked beans, peanut butter ($1.25 each)

Fried egg ($1.50) Pulled pork or brisket ($2)

Subs: Quinoa patty ($1), gluten-free bun ($1.50), grilled or fried chicken breast ($1)


Slow-smoked BBQ rubbed with love and served open-faced
with corn bread and choice of beans or greens.

Brisket Sandwich
Cheddar, bacon, house BBQ sauce, cole slaw, pickles. $9.95

Big Pig Sandwich
Pulled Pork, cole slaw, house BBQ sauce, pickles. $8.95

BBQ Sundae
Pulled pork, baked beans, coleslaw, and a pickle spear served in a mason jar with a cornbread muffin. $8.95


Uncured, nitrate free, grass-fed beef hot dogs served on split-top buns.

mustard and kraut $3.99

Chili Cheese Dog
chili, cheddar, onions $4.99

hot dog, pulled pork, bacon, slaw $5.99

The Works
mustard, relish, onions, tomato, banana peppers, pickles, celery salt $4.99

GENERATION Z (kidz menu)

Includes kid-sized fries. 12 years old and younger.

Z-Burger $5.95

Mac-N-Cheese $4.95

All-Natural Hot Dog $5.95

Fresh, All-Natural Chicken Strips $6.95

Crustless Grilled Cheese $4.95


Hand Cut Fries $2.95

Salt-n-Vinegar Fries $3.25

Cajun Fries $3.25

Sweet Potato Fries $3.95

Sea Salt And Truffle Fries $3.95

Chili-Cheese Fries $4.99

Bacon, Egg & Cheese Fries $6.99

4AM At The Diner Fries (gravy and cheese) $4.99

Mouth Of The South (sweet potato fries, smoked brisket, cheese, fried egg) $7.99

Dips: Organic Ketchup, LOCAL Sauce, House BBQ Sauce, Horseradish Mayo, Garlic Aioli, Sriracha Aioli, Maple Mayo, Honey Mustard, Ranch.

***Choose 1 dip per order. Additional dips $0.50 each.


Beer-Battered Onion Rings $4.99

Fiddy-Fiddy (fries and onion rings) $3.99

Fried Horseradish Pickle Chips $4.99

Slaw $2.79

Southern Style Baked Beans $2.79

Greens of the Day $2.99

Cup of Chili (topped with cheese) $2.99

Corn Bread Muffin $1.89

Mac-N-Cheese $2.95

Hush Puppies $3.99


All Natural Cane Sugar Fountain Soda (16oz.) $2.79
Cola, Lemon Lime, Black Cherry, Grape, Creme, Ginger Ale, Orange

Saranac Draught Root Beer $4.50
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade $2.95
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea $2.95
Mexican Coca Cola
Diet Coke $2.79
Bottled Water $1.89
Apple Juice $2.79 Milk $2.79 Chocolate Milk $2.79

Vanilla, chocolate, or black and white $6.00
Coyles of Bay Shore
Make it a malted - add $.50
Shake-of-the-Month $6.50

Floats Natural cola, orange, or grape float  $6.00
Saranac root beer float  $6.50


Local Manhattan
Widow Jane rye, carpano antico, bitters, Boylan’s black cherry splash. $10

NY Rum Punch
Montauk Coconut Rum, Owneys, & Sag Harbor rums with fresh juices & fruit. $9

El Local
Casa Noble organic reposado tequila, liqueur de l’orange, agave nectar, lime. $10

Root & Rye
Widow Jane Rye, Saranac Draught Root Beer, rock candy stick. $10

House-made red wine sangria with local wine, brandy, fresh fruit. $9

Whiskey Cooler
Beacon whiskey, Boylan’s Black Cherry, orange twist. $9

Local Mary
Spicy house-made Bloody Mary with Tito’s vodka & horseradish pickles. $9

Local Palmer
Fresh iced tea & lemonade, Tito’s vodka, mint. $9

LI Mule
Tito’s Vodka, organic ginger beer, fresh lime. $9

Dark N Stormy
Sag Harbor Rum, organic ginger beer, fresh lime. $9

Organic G&T
Farmers Organic Gin, grapefruit bitters, fresh lime. $9

"The End"
Montauk Coconut Rum, fresh squeezed lemonade, pineapple juice, lemon-lime can soda. $9

Local Burger Co

62 E Main Street, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Phone: 631-647-8300

Hours: Open daily 11:30am-10:00pm, Friday & Saturday open until 11:00pm